Skip to content

maybe a smarter choice needed? #15

@Sadi58

Description

@Sadi58

For me the output of the command apt-smart --list-mirrors is:

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Rank | Mirror URL                         | Available? | Updating? | Last updated    | Bandwidth   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|    1 | http://archive.ubuntu.com/ubuntu   | Yes        | No        | Up to date      | 335.33 KB/s |
|    2 | http://ubuntu.turhost.com/ubuntu   | Yes        | No        | 1 hour behind   | 708.1 KB/s  |
|    3 | http://ubuntu.saglayici.com/ubuntu | Yes        | No        | 3 hours behind  | 430.89 KB/s |
|    4 | http://ubuntu.vargonen.com/ubuntu  | Yes        | No        | 3 hours behind  | 122.09 KB/s |
|    5 | http://mirror.muvhost.com/ubuntu   | Yes        | No        | 4 hours behind  | 666.03 KB/s |
|    6 | http://mirror.ni.net.tr/ubuntu     | Yes        | No        | 12 hours behind | 588.75 KB/s |
|    7 | https://mirror.sh.com.tr/ubuntu    | Yes        | No        | 1 week behind   | 801.89 KB/s |
|    8 | http://ftp.linux.org.tr/ubuntu     | Yes        | Yes       | 4 hours behind  | 422.29 KB/s |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And the output of the command apt-smart --find-best-mirror is http://archive.ubuntu.com.
It seems to me that apt-smart is not taking into account the bandwidth (server speed) enough.
I fully agree that, in general, server speed is less important than the time since it was updated.
For instance, the server ranking 7 in the list could even be at the very bottom.
However, I think being merely “1 hour behind” should be considered less important than having less than half the speed.
Therefore, I think the 2nd server in the list should actually be selected as the best mirror.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions