Skip to content

Commit 4581908

Browse files
Copilotfermga
andcommitted
Add comprehensive documentation for RECEPTION dual-role implementation
Co-authored-by: fermga <203334638+fermga@users.noreply.github.com>
1 parent c2e084e commit 4581908

File tree

1 file changed

+188
-0
lines changed

1 file changed

+188
-0
lines changed

docs/RECEPTION_DUAL_ROLE.md

Lines changed: 188 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,188 @@
1+
# RECEPTION Dual-Role Frequency Classification
2+
3+
## Issue Resolution
4+
5+
**Issue**: [GRAMÁTICA CANÓNICA] Inconsistencia entre clasificación de frecuencias y reglas de bifurcación (P1)
6+
7+
**Problem**: Structural inconsistency between RECEPTION operator frequency classification and its role in graduated bifurcation rules (R4).
8+
9+
- RECEPTION classified as **medium** frequency in `STRUCTURAL_FREQUENCIES`
10+
- RECEPTION acts as **weak destabilizer** in graduated bifurcation windows
11+
- **Contradiction**: Medium νf cannot generate sufficient ΔNFR for ZHIR alone
12+
13+
## Theoretical Foundation
14+
15+
### Nodal Equation
16+
```
17+
∂EPI/∂t = νf · ΔNFR
18+
```
19+
20+
Where:
21+
- **νf**: Structural frequency (reorganization rate)
22+
- **ΔNFR**: Internal reorganization gradient (structural pressure)
23+
24+
### RECEPTION Dual Role
25+
26+
**Base Frequency (νf)**:
27+
- Classification: `medium`
28+
- Represents: Structural capture rate
29+
- Effect: Moderate reorganization capacity
30+
31+
**Destabilization Capacity (ΔNFR Generation)**:
32+
- Classification: `weak`
33+
- Condition: Requires prior coherent base
34+
- Effect: Can generate reorganization pressure when capturing external coherence into prepared node
35+
36+
## Solution: Hybrid Category (Option C)
37+
38+
### DUAL_FREQUENCY_OPERATORS Configuration
39+
40+
```python
41+
DUAL_FREQUENCY_OPERATORS: dict[str, dict[str, str]] = {
42+
RECEPTION: {
43+
"base_freq": "medium",
44+
"destabilization_capacity": "weak",
45+
"conditions": "requires_prior_coherence",
46+
"rationale": (
47+
"Captures external coherence which can generate ΔNFR when "
48+
"integrated into structurally prepared node"
49+
),
50+
}
51+
}
52+
```
53+
54+
### Context Validation
55+
56+
RECEPTION as weak destabilizer requires:
57+
58+
1. **Prior Stabilizer**: IL or THOL within 3 operators before EN
59+
2. **No Interruption**: No SILENCE between stabilizer and EN (would remove base)
60+
3. **Structural Preparation**: Node must have coherent base for EN to generate ΔNFR
61+
62+
### Valid Patterns
63+
64+
**AL → EN → IL → EN → ZHIR**
65+
- First EN captures
66+
- IL stabilizes (creates coherent base)
67+
- Second EN destabilizes with context
68+
- ZHIR enabled by EN-generated ΔNFR
69+
70+
**EN → IL → EN → ZHIR**
71+
- First EN captures
72+
- IL stabilizes
73+
- Second EN has context
74+
- ZHIR enabled
75+
76+
**OZ → IL → EN → ZHIR**
77+
- OZ provides strong destabilization
78+
- IL resolves
79+
- EN has context from resolution
80+
- ZHIR enabled by OZ (EN's context not needed when stronger destabilizer present)
81+
82+
### Invalid Patterns
83+
84+
**EN → ZHIR** (without context)
85+
- EN has no prior stabilizer
86+
- Medium νf alone insufficient for ZHIR
87+
- Violates structural coherence
88+
89+
**AL → EN → ZHIR** (no stabilization)
90+
- EN not stabilized by IL/THOL
91+
- No coherent base for destabilization
92+
- Cannot generate required ΔNFR
93+
94+
**AL → EN → IL → SHA → EN → ZHIR** (SILENCE interruption)
95+
- IL provides base
96+
- SHA removes base (νf → 0)
97+
- Second EN has no context
98+
- Cannot destabilize
99+
100+
## Implementation
101+
102+
### Files Modified
103+
104+
1. **src/tnfr/operators/grammar.py**
105+
- Added `DUAL_FREQUENCY_OPERATORS` constant
106+
- Implemented `_validate_reception_context()` method
107+
- Enhanced `_has_graduated_destabilizer()` with context validation
108+
- Added extensive documentation
109+
110+
2. **tests/unit/operators/test_reception_dual_role.py** (NEW)
111+
- 21 comprehensive tests
112+
- Coverage: valid contexts, invalid contexts, distance limits, SILENCE interruption
113+
- Backward compatibility validation
114+
115+
3. **tests/unit/operators/test_graduated_destabilizer_windows.py**
116+
- Updated 1 test for more precise error reporting
117+
118+
### Test Results
119+
120+
- ✅ 21/21 dual-role tests passing
121+
- ✅ 26/26 graduated destabilizer tests passing
122+
- ✅ 27/27 grammar module tests passing
123+
- ✅ 17/17 bifurcation tests passing
124+
-**Total: 91/91 related tests passing**
125+
126+
## Theoretical Implications
127+
128+
### Why Context Matters
129+
130+
From ∂EPI/∂t = νf · ΔNFR:
131+
132+
1. **Base Operation**: EN with medium νf provides moderate reorganization rate
133+
2. **Context Multiplication**: When EN captures external coherence into prepared node:
134+
- Integration creates structural tension
135+
- Tension manifests as ΔNFR
136+
- Product νf · ΔNFR sufficient for structural transformation
137+
3. **Without Context**: EN alone has medium νf but generates minimal ΔNFR
138+
- Insufficient product for ZHIR (requires high transformation energy)
139+
- Violates structural coherence principles
140+
141+
### Frequency vs. Destabilization
142+
143+
**Key Distinction**:
144+
- **Frequency (νf)**: Intrinsic reorganization capacity
145+
- **Destabilization (ΔNFR)**: Context-dependent gradient generation
146+
147+
**RECEPTION uniqueness**:
148+
- Medium base frequency (inherent property)
149+
- Weak destabilization capacity (contextual property)
150+
- First operator with explicit dual classification
151+
152+
## Future Considerations
153+
154+
### Potential Dual-Role Operators
155+
156+
Consider evaluating:
157+
- **COUPLING (UM)**: Medium frequency, could generate ΔNFR through synchronization
158+
- **TRANSITION (NAV)**: Medium frequency, already moderate destabilizer, possible context-dependent intensification
159+
- **RESONANCE (RA)**: High frequency, could have context-dependent amplification
160+
161+
### Telemetry Enhancement
162+
163+
Add tracking for:
164+
- Context validation decisions
165+
- RECEPTION destabilization success/failure rates
166+
- Distance between stabilizer and EN
167+
- SILENCE interruption frequency
168+
169+
### Documentation Updates
170+
171+
- [ ] Add to Mathematical Foundations document
172+
- [ ] Update operator reference with dual-role concept
173+
- [ ] Create visual diagrams for EN context patterns
174+
- [ ] Add examples to tutorials
175+
176+
## References
177+
178+
- **Issue**: GitHub Issue #[number]
179+
- **TNFR.pdf**: Section 2.1 - Ecuación Nodal
180+
- **Code**: `src/tnfr/operators/grammar.py:DUAL_FREQUENCY_OPERATORS`
181+
- **Tests**: `tests/unit/operators/test_reception_dual_role.py`
182+
- **Theory**: Resonant Fractal Nature Theory - Bifurcation and Emergence
183+
184+
---
185+
186+
**Implementation Date**: 2025-11-08
187+
**Status**: ✅ Complete and Tested
188+
**Backward Compatibility**: ✅ Preserved

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)